Windows versions: how users rate them from worst to best (history, controversies, and evolution)

Who hasn't had a strong opinion about a particular version of Windows? From those nostalgic for the unmistakable Windows XP wallpaper to those who suffered through (and cursed) the dreaded blue screens of death in Windows ME or Vista, every Microsoft release has left its mark on millions of users. Windows has evolved radically since 1985, going from simple graphical environments to becoming the dominant operating system for consumer and business computers worldwide.

Today, we're going to explore every version of Windows , analyzing them from the most criticized to the most highly rated by the community, unraveling the reasons for their successes and failures, the controversies, the influence of the legendary rivalry with Apple, and how our expectations have changed generation after generation. If you've ever wondered whether that myth of "good and bad" versions of Windows has any basis, here's your answer. Get comfortable, because this journey is packed with anecdotes, history, and plenty of everyday computing knowledge.

The Birth of Windows: The Jump from the Command Line

In the mid-80s, personal computers were almost exclusively the domain of geeks and engineers. Microsoft, founded by Bill Gates and Paul Allen in 1975, wanted to change this , and their idea was simple: to allow anyone to interact with the computer using windows, menus, and a mouse, without typing mysterious commands in the MS-DOS terminal. Thus began the "Interface Manager" project, which would eventually become known worldwide as Windows.

The first version of Windows was released in 1985, and although it may seem like a relic today, it laid the foundation for the modern user experience . However, it wasn't a complete operating system, nor was its success guaranteed: it was more of an experimental attempt to improve the accessibility of MS-DOS. Figures who would later shape the company's history, such as Steve Ballmer, the future CEO, participated in its development.

The first versions: Windows 1.x and 2.x (1985-1987)

The first two versions of Windows weren't exactly known for their power or popularity . Windows 1.0 was barely a graphical "layer" on top of MS-DOS, rudimentary in design and limited in capabilities. It allowed you to open programs like Paint, a basic calculator, and little else. Its biggest contribution was (beware) an electronic calendar and the ability to use a mouse, which at the time was a technological rarity.

With Windows 2.0 (1987), the first steps toward the modern desktop arrived: the ability to overlap windows, basic icon manipulation, and the appearance of the first versions of Word and Excel. The change was subtle for the general public, but it did represent a technical advance. Despite this, its popularity remained low , and the interface was still very immature compared to that of Apple's Macintosh.

Windows 2.0 also saw the introduction of the first Control Panel and the appearance of version 2.1, a minor improvement that included MS Paint, but without major commercial impact.

The start of success: Windows 3.x and the democratization of computing (1990-1992)

The real revolution came with Windows 3.0 and the 3.1/3.11 update . Now, millions of homes and businesses truly began to familiarize themselves with desktops, icons, and the concept of simple multitasking. Support for TrueType fonts and the first steps toward network connectivity marked a significant leap forward; in addition, Microsoft added games like Minesweeper and Solitaire , which undoubtedly helped many learn to use the mouse through play.

Windows 3.x was the first version to achieve real commercial success , competing head-to-head with Macintoshes and truly popularizing the concept of a graphical operating system. This generation marked the consolidation of the graphical interface, although it still relied, technically, on the old MS-DOS system.

The leap to the mainstream: Windows 95 and the arrival of modernity

The launch of Windows 95 in August of that year was the computing equivalent of the Beatles' arrival in the United States. A true mass phenomenon: for the first time, it incorporated the Start menu, the taskbar, and Plug and Play , which allowed users to connect peripherals without (so much) trouble with drivers . There was no longer any need to type commands or restart the computer for the mouse to work; everything was easier, more visual, and more user-friendly.

The marketing campaign was phenomenal, and although Windows 95 had its share of bugs and limitations, it forever changed the home computing experience . In just a few months, it captured over 60% of the global PC market. It was also the first version to include Internet Explorer and allow web browsing, as well as supporting the FAT32 file system and the first multimedia experiences.

However, it wasn't all sunshine and roses. Windows 95 suffered from stability issues and was plagued with crashes , especially before its successive Service Packs. Even so, it formed the foundation upon which the digital culture of an entire generation was built.

Windows 98: The PC connects to the world and the first criticisms emerge

Few operating systems have left as much of an impact as Windows 98. This version, released three years later, improved the interface and hardware management , becoming more stable and opening the system to new peripherals thanks to USB and DVD support. It also allowed internet sharing between multiple computers and introduced an improved version of Internet Explorer.

Despite these improvements, Windows 98 was also criticized for its slowness and security problems . The dreaded "blue screen of death" was a common sight, and the standard version was sometimes unreliable. The Second Edition (SE) corrected many bugs and is remembered as the most stable and robust of the 9x series.

The success was such that Windows 98 became the favorite system of gamers and computer enthusiasts of the time, with the definitive support of DirectX and the proliferation of games such as Age of Empires or Half-Life.

The disaster: Windows Me (Millennium Edition, 2000)

If we're looking for the least popular version of Windows in history, Windows Me takes the cake . Its launch was an absolute fiasco due to a mix of instability, recurring bugs, and compatibility issues . Although it attempted to add features like system restore and improved multimedia, the user experience left much to be desired: rampant blue screens, crashes during installation, and a very limited driver base.

User reaction was so negative that many quickly switched to Windows 98 SE or, shortly after, to XP as soon as it became available. Millennium became the classic example of a "bad" version of Windows, criticized even by Microsoft itself.

Professionalization: Windows 2000 and the NT branch

Alongside the evolution of home operating systems, Microsoft was perfecting a more secure and robust line for professional environments: the Windows NT family. Windows 2000 was the last before the unification of the product lines with XP, standing out for its stability, improved hardware support, NTFS file system , and, above all, greater security for businesses . However, its hardware requirements were high for the time, and it never gained widespread popularity among the general public, remaining a favorite in offices, banks, and on servers.

The Turning Point: Windows XP and 2001st-Century Computing (XNUMX)

The arrival of Windows XP marked a turning point in the history of personal computing. It combined the stability of the NT branch with the flexibility and ease of use of consumer versions , so that, for the first time, home users and businesses shared almost the same operating environment.

XP reigned supreme for over a decade . Stable, flexible, fast, and easy to use , XP was widely adopted by homes, businesses, and government agencies worldwide. Many will still remember that iconic wallpaper of green hills and blue sky, and its signature green Start button.

The arrival of DirectX 8 and DirectX 9 made XP the reference platform for gaming, while new features such as remote desktop, Wi-Fi support, managing multiple users without logging out, and native multimedia applications (Movie Maker, Media Player) made many everyday tasks easier.

Such was its success that the transition to new versions was resisted for years: even after the arrival of Windows 7 and Windows 10, XP remained in use well into the 2010s , although its support officially ended in 2014.

Windows Vista: A Broken Promise and a History of Controversy (2007)

After six years of XP's reign, Microsoft launched Windows Vista , with a radical shift towards design and security. The spectacular Aero interface (transparency, animations) and the strengthened User Account Control (UAC) were its major new features. But alas, Vista demanded very powerful hardware for the time , and most users experienced a drastic performance drop. Furthermore, compatibility with drivers and peripherals was practically nonexistent.

Criticisms multiplied due to these shortcomings, the slowness, and the enormous number of UAC notifications, which drove even the most patient user crazy. Despite being the precursor to changes that later became established (a redesign of the Start menu, security improvements), Vista went down in history as one of the most poorly reviewed versions of Windows, and its memory is associated with frustration and slowdowns.

Redemption: Windows 7 and the Satisfaction Consensus (2009)

In just two years, Microsoft regained user trust with Windows 7 , inheriting the best features of Vista but with a much more polished design. Fast, reliable, and compatible with most existing hardware, Windows 7 is considered by many to be the most complete version of Windows ever.

Among its main improvements are the redesigned taskbar, multi-touch support, file libraries, and optimized features for laptops and netbooks. All of this without compromising performance and while maintaining a visual experience adapted to new standards.

Windows 7 was widely adopted by all types of users and businesses, and its lifecycle extended until 2020, when Microsoft discontinued official support. Many computers continue to run on this platform, especially in environments where reliability is a priority.

Touch Stumble: Windows 8 and 8.1 (2012-2013)

Encouraged by the rise of tablets and touchscreens, Microsoft decided to reinvent Windows in 2012 with Windows 8. The result was a Metro interface based on tiles, which, while visually appealing for touch devices, proved incredibly confusing for mouse and keyboard users . The removal of the classic Start button and menu was the final blow; many either couldn't adapt or chose not to.

Despite new features like ultra-fast boot times , enhanced security options, and the integration of an app store, the poor reception forced Microsoft to quickly release Windows 8.1 , restoring the Start button and simplifying the user experience. It wasn't enough: a large portion of the user base remained on Windows 7 until something better came along.

Reunification: Windows 10, the "for everyone" experience (2015)

Windows 10 marked a major shift in philosophy for Microsoft. The idea was to combine the best features of previous versions, offering a seamless experience for both home users and businesses, and adaptable to both touch and traditional devices . The Start menu returned, accompanied by live tiles, virtual desktops, and a more polished interface.

Windows 10 also brought with it security improvements (Windows Hello, BitLocker), Cortana integration, the Edge browser, and, above all, a "Windows as a service" approach: updates are now continuous and free, which in principle benefits stability and security.

The Universal Windows Platform (UWP) aimed to incentivize developers, while advanced features like DirectX 12 and Xbox integration solidified Windows 10 as a versatile operating system. Despite some initial complaints about updates and data collection, it is now probably the most widely used version of Windows, especially in educational settings.

The Final Leap: Windows 11 and the Quest for the Modern Experience (2021-2024)

After more than six years of Windows 10, Windows 11 has arrived , the latest version and, at the same time, the most controversial in recent times. The first thing that stands out is the visual redesign: a centered taskbar, rounded corners, revamped menus, and a clear commitment to minimalism . The Start menu has changed again, now without tiles, and informative widgets have been enhanced.

Among its technical innovations are support for Android applications (albeit limited), performance and gaming improvements (DirectStorage, Auto HDR ), full Microsoft Teams integration , and a completely redesigned Microsoft Store. Furthermore, the hardware requirements are much stricter , notably requiring TPM 2.0 and systems with UEFI.

However, it hasn't escaped criticism : some users feel the interface changes are more cosmetic than genuine improvements, and compatibility with older hardware is a serious issue. The general perception is that Windows 11, while innovative, hasn't delivered the qualitative leap expected after the success of Windows 10.

"Weird" versions: Microsoft's curiosities and experiments

In addition to the mainstream versions, Microsoft has experimented with dozens of specific variants and editions of Windows, many of which are now genuine collector's items or curiosities for tech geeks:

• Windows CE for Dreamcast: Yes, SEGA's last console had a ported version of Windows, although almost no games actually took advantage of it.
• Windows 20th Anniversary Edition: An ultra-limited edition released only in Japan with Windows XP Professional and CD replicas of other versions, all very focused on collectors.
• China Government Edition: An edition ultra-lightly adapted to the Chinese government's security and privacy requirements, never before seen outside that country.
• Windows RT: A resounding failure, it attempted to bring Windows to the ARM ecosystem, but its incompatibility with x86 apps condemned it to oblivion.
• Windows Media Center Edition: A commitment to turning the PC into a multimedia center for the living room, limited by hardware and availability issues.

Windows 10 versions: dozen editions for every need

Windows 10 surprised everyone by going far beyond the classic Home, Pro, and Enterprise editions. Microsoft launched up to 12 different variants , each designed for very specific scenarios:

• Home and Pro: For home and professional use, including basic and advanced features (Cortana, BitLocker, Remote Desktop, etc.).
• Enterprise and Education: Focused on large companies and educational environments, with advanced security management, policy control, and volume licensing.
• IoT and Mobile: Designed for the "Internet of Things" and for the (now extinct) Windows Phones.
• Pro for Workstations and S: For advanced workstations and environments where only apps from the official app store are allowed.
• LTSB and Team: Editions for long-cycle devices, such as kiosks and interactive whiteboards (Surface Hub).

This extensive catalog reflects Microsoft's strategy of reaching every possible niche, although many of these versions are less well-known and have not had much impact on mainstream users.

Pattern of alternating between “good” and “bad” versions?

There's a widespread belief that Microsoft releases outstanding versions followed by disappointing ones . While there wasn't a clear pattern in the early years, a certain alternation became apparent at the beginning of the century.

• XP (good): Resounding success and longevity.
• Sight (bad): Serious problems and low acceptance.
• 7 (good): Great consensus and performance.
• 8/8.1 (bad): Confusing interface and user rejection.
• 10 (good): Stability and mass adoption.
• 11 (indefinite/bad): Visually appealing but with criticism and slow adoption.

This cycle seems to respond more to social perception and market response than to a predefined pattern, and reflects the difficulty of innovating without losing user trust.

Historical controversies: security, privacy, lawsuits and resistance to change

There have been numerous controversies surrounding Windows. The most notable are:

• Security issues: Viruses and vulnerabilities have been a constant problem, although Microsoft has improved over time.
• Problematic updates: They have caused data loss and crashes, especially with the switch to Windows as a Service in Windows 10.
• Antitrust lawsuits: Like the dispute over the integration of Internet Explorer, which almost led to the split of the giant.
• Privacy: Data collection in Windows 10 and 11 has sparked debate about user control.
• Resistance to innovation: Radical changes in the interface (Vista, 8, 11) have caused rejection among some users.

The Microsoft vs. Apple rivalry: two approaches, same users

Microsoft and Apple have always been at the center of one of the most well-known rivalries in technology . Although Apple accused Microsoft of copying its interface, over time both companies have learned to coexist and collaborate. Advertising campaigns and comparisons keep the rivalry alive, but many users use products from both brands without issue.

Why is Windows the absolute king?

Windows' dominance is explained not only by marketing, but by several key factors:

• Huge ecosystem of software and hardware: compatibility is complete.
• Agreements with manufacturers: Most computers come with Windows pre-installed.
• Adaptability to all niches: from home to business and gaming.
• Integration with other Microsoft services: Office, OneDrive, Teams…

These reasons, along with the familiarity acquired through decades of use, explain why Windows remains the benchmark operating system worldwide.

The future: Windows 12 and more AI?

Microsoft will continue to focus on artificial intelligence and innovation in Windows. Features like Copilot , cross-device compatibility, and cloud integration will be essential in future releases.

Windows 12 is expected to be released in late 2024 or early 2025, with a deeper focus on AI, higher technical requirements, and an experience focused on productivity and security.

After nearly forty years, Windows has gone from being an experimental project to becoming a fundamental pillar of digital society . Throughout its history, it has reflected the aspirations, successes, and failures of its time, adapting to industry changes and constant competition. While a "perfect Windows" can never be defined, it has undeniably marked a turning point in our digital lives.

Related articles:

Windows 25: Everything you need to know about the concept, its origins, functions, and the context of the real versions and mods