Chocolatey vs. Winget: The Ultimate Comparison of Package Managers on Windows

In the Windows world, managing software installation and updates can be a real headache. Between failed dependencies, missing packages, and wasted time searching for download links, the experience isn't always ideal. Fortunately, there are alternatives that simplify this task, such as package managers.

Chocolatey and Winget are two of the most popular package managers in Windows. Both allow you to install, update, and remove applications from the command line. commands quickly and automatically. But which is better? In this article we tell you the Key differences, strengths and limitations of each to help you decide which best suits your needs.

What is a package manager and what is it used for in Windows?

A package manager is a tool that automates the installation, updating, and management of software. They are very common in systems such as Linux, where tools such as apt, yum o dnf are indispensable. In Windows, we have alternatives such as Chocolatey, Winget or Scoop.

Its main advantage is that They prevent the user from having to manually search for installers., worry about versions, or install packages one by one. With a simple command line, you can install Google Chrome, update Notepad++, or remove VLC, all without opening a single window with “next” buttons.

In addition, these managers They verify that the packages are virus-free and configured correctly, something that reduces errors and improves the reliability of the system. They also allow you to add custom repositories and run scripts with administrator permissions (when necessary).

Chocolatey: The veteran with the most muscle

Chocolate and It's been around for over a decade and has built a huge community around it. It's ideal for both individual users and businesses, as it comes in three editions:

• Open source: Free and widely used by individuals. Ideal for automating basic installations.
• Pro Edition: Adds protection against malware and reliability improvements.
• Chocolatey for Business (C4B): Focused on enterprise environments, it offers integration with DevOps pipelines, special licenses, package synchronization, and more.

Its installation requires configuring the execution policy of PowerShell and install a script from its official website. In return, you will have access to the largest catalog of Windows packages, with more than 9.500 programs available, including Microsoft Teams, Google Chrome, Notepad++, Adobe Reader, among others.

Chocolatey supports files .exe, .msi, .zip and even scriptsThis gives you great flexibility, especially if you want to automate processes across multiple teams. Plus, it integrates very well with automation tools like Ansible.

Download Chocolatey

Winget: Microsoft's growing bet

Winget, also known as Windows Package Manager, is Microsoft's official alternative. It was released in 2020 and It comes preinstalled on many versions of Windows 10 and 11, or it can be installed from the Microsoft Store.

Winget stands out for being easier to install and use Chocolatey. By integrating with the operating system, you don't need to modify the script execution policy or take any additional steps. Simply open PowerShell and type commands like:

winget install chrome

As for repositories, Winget uses its own community managed by Microsoft, and also includes apps from the Microsoft Store. Although its catalog is smaller than Chocolatey's, It already has more than 8000 applications available.

Its focus is on offering a solution stable, light and easy to useIt is especially recommended for users who only need to install basic software without worrying about advanced settings.

Download Winget

Installation: Which is more accessible?

Installing Winget is as simple as searching for “App Installer” in the Microsoft Store and clicking “Install”, or checking if you already have it running winget and PowerShell.

Chocolatey, on the other hand, requires:

• Run PowerShell with administrator permissions
• Adjust execution policies with specific commands
• Run the installation script from the official website

Winget wins in simplicity of installation, especially for less technical users. However, Chocolatey offers the option of using graphical interfaces like Chocolatey GUI for ease of use.

Advanced features and automation

If you are looking to automate tasks within corporate environments or servers, Chocolatey has more features. Allows you to define complex scripts, integrate internal servers, and control software versions across multiple terminals.

Winget, on the other hand, also allows:

• Update all packages with a single command
• Add or remove third-party repositories
• Search, view details, or delete packages

It also includes some handy features like package synchronization with external versions. It doesn't reach the level of automation Chocolatey offers in corporate environments, but It more than fulfills its purpose for individual use..

Which manager has the most packages available?

In this point, Chocolatey is the clear winner. With over 9500 active packages, its repository includes everything from system utilities to development programs, databases, editors, browsers and much more.

Winget, although it has grown rapidly, has just over 8000 packages in its community. It includes common applications such as 7-Zip, Firefox, VLC, and Zoom, but It has not yet reached the width of Chocolatey.

For basic tasks, both managers will work. But if you need to install niche or very specific software, it's probably available first in Chocolatey.

Support, documentation and community

Chocolatey, having been on the market for several years, has a larger community. It has an active forum, hundreds of step-by-step guides, detailed documentation, and production use cases.

Winget, being newer, is still building its community. Microsoft offers official documentation, but some users report that it isn't always clear. for startersHowever, its integration with GitHub allows for open collaboration and ecosystem improvement.

In any case, Both have enough support to learn how to use them quickly, especially if you are already familiar with the command line.

Deciding between Chocolatey and Winget depends primarily on your needs. If you're looking for an ultra-lightweight, Windows-integrated, and ready-to-use solution, Winget is a perfect choice. But if you're an advanced user, a system administrator, or simply want more control, Chocolatey offers a more complete and professional environment.